Financial Times FT.com

Hedge fund scandals

Published: October 29 2009 14:42 | Last updated: October 29 2009 22:22

Short-selling hedge funds, Morgan Stanley’s chief financial officer supposedly said during the depths of last year’s crisis, are like “cold blooded reptiles. They eat what’s in front of them.” Lately, however, some hedge funds have more closely resembled a house of cards, where a single knock can bring the whole thing down. Indictments for alleged insider trading from the Federal Bureau of Investigation and Securities and Exchange Commission are undoing Galleon. Meanwhile K1, a European fund of funds, may quickly come under pressure after German prosecutors said they were investigating possible fraud by its founder, Helmut Kiener.

If the allegations against Galleon and K1 are proved, such scandals – alongside Bernard Madoff’s – will be different in form but still have two things in common. The first is the length of time they allegedly carried on their game. Prosecutors claim Galleon’s insider trading scheme dates back to at least January 2006. Mr Kiener allegedly kept his creditors in the dark long enough to land them with about $400m of losses. And Mr Madoff spent years executing his Ponzi scheme.

Second, and more importantly, is how each of these operations posed little systemic risk. Unlike their bailed-out banking peers, individual hedge funds regularly fold – or blow up. Investors then withdraw their remaining funds and the financial world rolls on. Retribution is swift but the broader impact is small. Hedge fund assets have fallen from around $4,000bn two years ago to a quarter of that now, according to BarclayHedge. Yet no government bail-out has been seen.

Recent scandals suggest there is a need for better rules governing hedge fund disclosure and investor protection. But when it comes to systemic risk, although herding can in theory be a problem, hedge funds’ relatively small size means macro-prudential regulators would do better to focus their efforts on banks.

More Lex in this sector

US litigation

Bonus windfall tax

Goldman Sachs

Apollo

Bernanke blowing bubbles

Ukraine

Bank accounting rules

New York’s cash crisis

Bear Stearns

US bank regulation

Tobin or not Tobin

Jobs and classifieds

Jobs

Search
Type your search criteria below:

Global Head of Aftersales

Material Handling Capital Equipment

Non-Executive Director

The Housing Finance Corporation

Chief Executive Officer

Financial Services Group

Executive Director

Harvard Shanghai Center

Recruiters

FT.com can deliver talented individuals across all industries around the world

Post a job now